WE BUY CARDS

We buy cards! Bring your stuff in and we're always happy to look. Send us pictures on Instagram! Or send us an email at cardshopnearmenj@gmail.com to schedule a time.

We are MOST INTERESTED in cards $20 and over. We don't do a lot of bulk so we are not the shop to sell your bulk to (bulk is cards that sell in the $1 to $5 range). We are more like a boutique that has a smaller number of rare items.

We pay up to 70% present card value in cash.

We offer up to 80% present card value in a trade.

We determine card value using recent sales from major marketplaces. We will show you the sales we are basing our valuation on. Then, we will offer you a percentage of our valuation based on these recent sales, with higher percentages for more in-demand and higher-end items. You are free to accept or decline our offers for each card. We inventory everything in a spreadsheet that we are happy to share with you.

Everything here is at our discretion. We use sites like alt.xyz, pricecharting.com, 130point.com, tcgplayer.com, and ebay.com to determine prices, and we encourage you to check your card values too! Generally, you will get a bit better percentage for knowing what recent sales are making the transaction quick for both of us!