WE BUY CARDS + SEALED

We buy cards and sealed items! Bring your stuff in and we're always happy to look. Send us pictures on Instagram! Or send us an email at cardshopnearmenj@gmail.com to send us info.

IF YOU HAVE > 10 CARDS TO SELL PLEASE SEND US A LIST BY EMAIL OR IG IN ADVANCE. We get a lot of buying requests and are trying to streamline our process.

If you have a COLLECTION where it is not possible to inventory it, send us a general description and we'll work with you.

Right now we are buying all values of MTG and Pokemon but only buying > $100 sports cards. We buy all sorts of Pokemon and MTG stuff but are very picky about sports cards. See below for details.

Please contact us ahead of time for best results. All buying is at our discretion and we may decline to buy for any reason at any time.

Payment guide

These are rough estimates

TCG

*Card or Product Value* *Cash* *Store Credit*
True Bulk (commons, etc) $3 per thousand $4 per thousand
$1-2 card 30% card value 40% card value
$2-10 40% card value 50% card value
$10-30 50% card value 60% card value
$30+ 60+% card value 65+% card value

 

SPORTS

*Card Value* *Cash* *Store Credit*
True Bulk (commons, etc) Not interested Not interested
$1-20 card Not interested Not interested
$20-100 Not interested Not interested
$100+ 50-100% card value 50-100% card value

 

For sports we buy a small number of players, mostly in basketball. We are happy to pay 90-100% for these players for the right cards. Right now we are looking for

  • Tyrese Maxey
  • Jalen Brunson
  • Trey Murphy
  • Christian Braun
  • Franz Wagner
  • Cam Thomas

For these players, we pay well. For all other sports cards $100+, we offer only around 50% if we decide to buy.

Again, everything here is completely at our discretion. We are not promising to buy anything. For best results, contact us.

SELLING LOTS

If you have a large lot of TCG, particularly a large lot where cards are in the $0-$3 range, you may have best luck selling to Card Kingdom. It is going to be hard for us to make strong offers on large lots that do not contain any higher end items. For instance, a lot of 1000x $1 cards is not something we are super interested in, although we will be able to give you something for them if you're just looking to get rid of them.

How to price your stuff

We use the following sites to determine prices

With TCGPlayer please look at "TCG low", which is the lowest price you can currently buy the card for from a reputable seller. This will be different than the "market price", which is often wrong.